AEW Saturday Tailgate Brawl Results – Sept. 20, 2025 – All Out 2025 Pre-Show, 8-Woman Tailgate Brawl

Sep 20, 2025

September 20, 2025
Toronto, Ontario, Canada – Scotiabank Arena
Commentary – Tony Schiavone, Nigel McGuinness, and “Daddy Magic” Matt Menard
Results via Ryan Howard of F4WOnline.com

Quick Match Results

The Opps defeated The WorkHorsemen via Coquina Clutch (submission)
Daniel Garcia defeated Katsuyori Shibata via Arm Trapped Curb Stomp (pinfall)
Trios match – Paragon & Hologram defeated The Frat House via Top Rope Double Foot Stomp (pinfall)
8-Woman Tailgate Brawl match

The Opps (Powerhouse Hobbs & Samoa Joe) vs. The WorkHorsemen (Anthony Henry & JD Drake)

Tony Schiavone, Matt Menard & Nigel McGuinness are on the call, as The Workhorsemen were already in the ring during The Opps entrance. Henry tried firing off early strikes on Hobbs, who didn’t budge, opting to hit a huge series of bodyslams before Drake saved his partner, only to eat one himself. Joe tagged in and peppered Drake with strikes and running senton. Drake got in an eye rake and chop, leading to an assisted Tornado DDT from Henry, but Joe was out at one. Fast tags from The Workhorsemen until Joe caught Drake with a snap powerslam for the double down.

Hobbs made the tag and ran wild with splashes and meat clotheslines in the corner, mowing down Henry before Joe tagged back in with a corner enzugiri on Drake. Fighting off a Muscle Buster, Drake tried a dive, but Joe did the signature walk away before sinking in the Coquina Clutch. Hobbs laid out Henry with a spinebuster while Drake tapped out.

Winner: The Opps via Submission.

As The Opps celebrated on the stage, the music for Katsuyori Shibata hit and it led to our next match.

Katsuyori Shibata vs. Daniel Garcia

Garcia has a Death Riders mix for his music, as he made his way through the crowd with Shafir and was met with loud You Sold Out chants as Shibata sprinted at him with a running boot to start. Garcia bailed to the floor before Shibata could get his stalling dropkick, as the two brawled, where Shibata sent Garcia crashing into almost every corner of the barricade as things went to commercial.

When things returned, Garcia caught Shibata with a DDT on the floor until Menard left commentary, getting in the face of Garcia, screaming for answers, but Garcia never looked at him. Instead, Garcia trapped Shibata’s head between the ring steps and dropkicked them in a brutal looking spot. Garcia kept Shibata grounded back inside, but Shibata started firing up with strikes. Both traded German suplexes until Shibata stood tall, hitting his signature stalling dropkick and butterfly suplex for two. Shafir was screaming advice for Garcia to avoid the Shibata triangle choke. After a rope break, both fought to the apron for a forearm exchange until Garcia bit at the head, wanted a piledriver, but Shibata countered into a Death Valley Driver heading into another break.

We return to both men down as referee Stephon Smith put a 10 count on them, as both rose at 8 and swung away with forearms. Misdirect from Garcia into a guillotine, turned to a piledriver, but Shibata kicked out. Garcia delivered another piledriver, Shibata kicking out at one this time. Shibata fought back, wanted a PK, but still felt the effects of the piledrivers. Garcia charged, but right into a Rear Naked Choke, trapping the arm in the process. Marina Shafir jumped on the apron to distract the ref, as Garcia tapped out. Shibata went at Shafir, but Garcia blindsided Shibata, hitting a Gotch Style Piledriver and arm trapped Curb Stomp for the win.

Winner: Daniel Garcia via Pinfall.

Ringside: Renee Paquette, RJ City

The WrestleAunts, Renee Paquette & RJ City are ringside in their finest denim and they run down how you can watch All Out. They also tell us Copeland & Cage vs. FTR will kick off the show.

Trios Match
Paragon (Roderick Strong & Kyle O’Reilly) & Hologram vs. The Frat House (Griff Garrison, Cole Karter, & Preston Vance)

The Frat House attacked immediately, but that didn’t last long, as Strong used Hologram as a projectile to land a splash onto Garrison & Vance. Jameson distracted O’Reilly long enough for Karter to get in a cheap shot, as he was isolated soon after. O’Reilly was able to break free and tag Hologram, who used his speed to avoid all attacks, planting Garrison with a standing Spanish Fly. Vance was met with a triple team strike, before Strong took out Garrison with a baseball slide, while Hologram cleared the top rope with a dive onto Jameson & Frat House pledges. Top rope double stomp from Hologram on Garrison finished things quickly.

Winner: Paragon & Hologram via Pinfall.

Post-match, Strong still didn’t look happy with Hologram, despite O’Reilly being thrilled his team won. Ultimately, O’Reilly is going to have to decide between Paragon & The Conglomeration.

8-Woman Tailgate Brawl Match
Triangle of Madness (Julia Hart & Skye Blue), Megan Bayne, & Penelope Ford vs. Willow Nightingale, Mina Shirakawa, Harley Cameron, & Queen Aminata

Blue wielded a staplegun during her entrance, as Nightingale’s team all charged at the opposition like a football team. They all ripped their AEW shirts off, but that delay allowed the heels to attack from behind. Bayne launched Ford over her head onto a pile outside, missing Nightingale taking out Triangle of Madness, leading to a face-off with Bayne and yay/boo chants in a strike exchange. Bayne ran into a spinebuster, as all the ladies got back in the ring, trying for a quadruple snap suplex, with the babyfaces winning that battle. Weapons started coming into play, as Ford & Aminata swung at one another with a ladle and tongs, while it looked like Cameron was about to use the staplegun in the ring on Blue, but it cut to commercial before we could see anything.

Back from break, Blue cut off Nightingale in the corner, saving Hart and hitting a powerbomb onto a cooler. Shirakawa started swinging the cooler as Aminata gave Hart some Chocolate Kisses. Assisted Tornillo from Shirakawa, until the heels regained control, placing a trash can over Cameron in the corner, as her teammates were sent crashing into her. Handspring elbow from Ford led to a moonsault off Bayne’s back, but Cameron kicked out. Bayne screamed orders, as Ford went up for a Doomsday, but Nightingale made the save, sending Ford crashing outside. Cameron got free and sent Bayne into a Pounce by Nightingale. Aminata & Shirakawa broke a table over Bayne’s face ringside, while Hart & Blue were pulled outside and sent into the barricade. Shirakawa set up a BBQ grill, as Aminata put the lid on top of Hart & Blue’s head, booting it. Back inside, Nightingale waffled Ford with a trash can before putting her away with a Doctor Bomb. Post match, Aminata & Shirakawa held the coolers like boomboxes, while Nightingale danced with a cooler on her head.

Winner: Willow Nightingale, Mina Shirakawa, Harley Cameron, & Queen Aminata via Pinfall.

AEW Saturday Tailgate Brawl